« ALEA Home | Email msg. | Reply to msg. | Post new | Board info. Previous | Home | Next

Re: Thoreau (cactus flower reply)

By: Fiz in ALEA | Recommend this post (0)
Mon, 12 Sep 22 9:29 PM | 24 view(s)
Boardmark this board | The Trust Matrix
Msg. 47009 of 54809
(This msg. is a reply to 47004 by Cactus Flower)

Jump:
Jump to board:
Jump to msg. #

Hi Cactus Flower,

I think if you read more about him, combined with reading more of what he wrote, you might be very favorably impressed. He was a classic liberal who did his best to practice what he preached, sometimes at great personal cost. For example, he spent a long time in jail for refusing to financially or otherwise support war and slavery.

If I remember correctly, you are not American - which would explain why you don't know of Thoreau. Americans have no similarly good reason for not knowing. I don't know much about the great men and women in English history who paid dearly for protesting injustice in your country. Perhaps you might suggest a few luminaries from your own history?

As you may have observed, most "Christians" and non-Christians, regardless of political party or supposed ethical beliefs, are just fine with reaping benefits of exploiting innocents...so long as someone else does it for them, they can pretend they "didn't know", and they don't have to get their hands visibly dirty. What I call "evil by proxy" accounts for nearly all the killing and other ugliness in the world.

As I'm sure we both know, MOST people are massively hypocritical when it comes to paying a personal price for what they, supposedly, believe. Thoreau was a close friend of Ralph Waldo Emerson, and perhaps you know the latter somewhat better?


http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_David_Thoreau

http://sites.psu.edu/henrydavid/2015/04/30/thoreau-on-slavery/

"Thoreau’s Slavery in Massachusetts essay is based off a speech he gave at an anti-slavery rally in Massachusetts after the decision was made to send free/runaway slaves that were living up north back to slavery in the south; Fugitive Slave Act. In particular a fugitive slave, Anthony Burns, was re-enslaved in Boston, Mass. Thoreau’s anti-slavery views expressed throughout the essay are one’s of American Romantic’s preoccupation with democracy and freedom. During the time American Romantic writing was all about the values we separated from Britain on. The only problem was everyone was talking about freedom and democracy but weren’t living up to those values they held on to so tightly; slaves weren’t allowed freedom and democracy played against them. Thoreau gives examples after examples of how ass backwards and hypocritical these “people” of the US are, caring more about slaves than matters of citizenship like when he states, “The whole military force of the state is at service of a Mr. Suttle, a slaveholder from Virginia, to enable him to catch a man whom he calls his property; but not a soldier is offered to save a citizen of Massachusetts from being kidnapped” but aren’t they supposed to be about the people about freedom and democracy? Thoreau makes such good points on why enslaving people are wrong but yet the very same people who rebelled against enslavement in a way can’t see their wrong doing. It makes you wonder was this essay even effective and if so what would be the reaction?
---

Anyway, I think Thoreau is one of the greatest Americans who ever lived in terms of heart, intellect, influence, AND (most important of all) MORAL INTEGRITY.


- - - - -
View Replies (1) »



» You can also:
- - - - -
The above is a reply to the following message:
Re: Thoreau
By: Cactus Flower
in ALEA
Mon, 12 Sep 22 3:31 PM
Msg. 47004 of 54809

I think I recognise that quote from a poster with a different handle, don't I?

Here's what I remember thinking last time.

Was Thoreau a wise man?

Or merely a condescending one, as the quote suggests, and in want of a mirror?

Personally, I prefer my heroes to be humble. Arrogance is not a persuasive pulpit.

Or put another way, if a person was chief of the association of village idiots, would they not presume themselves to be the hero-patriot identified by Thoreau?

I recommend searching for a new author with a little more self-awareness.


« ALEA Home | Email msg. | Reply to msg. | Post new | Board info. Previous | Home | Next