« 6TH POPE Home | Email msg. | Reply to msg. | Post new | Board info. Previous | Home | Next

Russia is What . . . 

By: Zimbler0 in 6TH POPE | Recommend this post (1)
Sat, 25 Feb 23 4:49 AM | 26 view(s)
Boardmark this board | 6th Edition Pope Board
Msg. 40461 of 58545
(This msg. is a reply to 40453 by Fiz)

Jump:
Jump to board:
Jump to msg. #

Fiz > There is another important point which is, perhaps, subtle but still worth meditating on: countries are NOT governments. They are not the geography, either.

"Russia"...as Russia, and even its current government, is QUITE distinct from the GOVERNMENT (fictitious entity) known as the USSR. The PEOPLE of who lived in the geographic region we call "Russia" were overwhelmingly anti-Communist by the time the USSR collapsed. Indeed, that is WHY it collapsed; the people had had enough - even if the "government" had not.

I suspect the US is much more "Marxist" now than is Russia. Just saying.;->
>>>


Fiz > countries are NOT governments. They are not the geography, either.


Zim: And here I been thinking for most of my life that a 'country' was the amalgamation of the land it occupies, the government which manages the joint, and the people living in that geographic region.

In fact I would postulate that without real estate - as in 'geographical property' to call its own - one cannot have a 'country'.

One can have a 'People'. Take the Israeli's before they got their chunk of the Middle East. They were a 'People'. But they lived under the tax laws and regulations of whatever 'country' they lived within. Today the Israeli's have their own chunk of 'Geography' and they write their own tax laws etc. etc. etc.

Today Russia IS what Russia is in large part because of their 'government'. The USSR was what it was because of the government.


America is today what it is because 'We' LET our 'government' do to U.S. what has been done to U.S.

Zim.




Avatar

Mad Poet Strikes Again.




» You can also:
- - - - -
The above is a reply to the following message:
Re: World Superpowers Threw Their Cards on the Table This Week
By: Fiz
in 6TH POPE
Sat, 25 Feb 23 2:14 AM
Msg. 40453 of 58545

De: I just gave you a star.

That said, under MY prefered (most useful) definition of "losing", both the US and USSR lost their respective wars. Please consider: they came out vastly worse off for the experience. They came out vastly impoverished, vastly demoralized, vastly reduced in world stature, etc. from what they were when the entered their respective wars. They LOST.

Indeed, virtually all wars in human history end with TWO (or all) LOSERS. It is pretty rare for a country to exit a war having really profited/benefited enough from the experience to really call them a "winner". That is most of the point I keep trying to make here, which some seem unable to even consider. But it is true...or, at least, true enough, especially considering value differences.

There is another important point which is, perhaps, subtle but still worth meditating on: countries are NOT governments. They are not the geography, either.

"Russia"...as Russia, and even its current government, is QUITE distinct from the GOVERNMENT (fictitious entity) known as the USSR. The PEOPLE of who lived in the geographic region we call "Russia" were overwhelmingly anti-Communist by the time the USSR collapsed. Indeed, that is WHY it collapsed; the people had had enough - even if the "government" had not.

I suspect the US is much more "Marxist" now than is Russia. Just saying.;->


« 6TH POPE Home | Email msg. | Reply to msg. | Post new | Board info. Previous | Home | Next