Forum Home | Log in | Signup | My Page | Rules | FAQ | Boards | Members | Search
« 6TH POPE Home | Email msg. | Reply to msg. | Post new | Board info. Previous | Home | Next

Re: The Failing Ukraine Counteroffensive And It's UGLY Aftermath 

By: Fiz in 6TH POPE | Recommend this post (1)
Thu, 22 Jun 23 3:29 PM | 32 view(s)
Boardmark this board | 6th Edition Pope Board 		Msg. 43707 of 58519
(This msg. is a reply to 43703 by Zimbler0)
Jump:
Jump to board:
Jump to msg. #

Zim,

I notice that slavery has been, as it has to be, REDEFINED in order to make your assertion. That is a cunning trap.

So things like child marriage makes up most of the world's population of slaves under this redefinition. But "child" has a slippery (non stated) definition. Is it 21, or 18, or 16, or puberty, or is it based on intellectual and emotional development? So arranged marriages, and underage marriages, must all be “slavery”, regardless of whether they are culturally or biologically supported? Regardless of whether they end up as lifetime, reasonably fulfilling relationships and propagate the families?

Let's face it, few if any ever stop maturing. And I'd argue at least half the population NEVER takes responsibility for themselves and stops looking for "entitlements". so more than half the population ever escapes childhood. So more than half the population is rooked into marriage one way or another. So more than half the population is ENSLAVED according to your source definition?

I know a lot of men and women who are trapped in marriages they can't escape, even though they are profoundly unhappy and feel compelled to continue? And legally sanctioned. Very akin to prostitutes with pimps, in many cases. Certainly not free; absolutely not free to leave. So..."slavery"?

And military personnel, they can't leave without being sanctioned, jailed, or worse? Do you think the citizens in Ukraine can all leave? You can bet your bippy, the vast majority want to. Wasn't the draft a form of slavery?

But THAT IS INTELLECTUALLY DISHONEST and leads to Stinking Thinking, subjugation to authority, and atrocities like the Forever War when you allow words to be redefined to meet your desired outcome half way.

*I* would say that "taxation without representation" is just as much a form of slavery as childhood marriage. I am represented by this government not at all. So *I* am a "slave", by your own weak logic.

And, therefore, since next to nobody on the planet is represented by the authorities which tax them, ALL EIGHT BILLION PLUS OF US ARE SLAVES.

Now, in truth, I actually do think nearly all humans on this planet are slaves. Certainly I think you are. But if you are going to present arguments based on words, and allow the words to be ill-defined, you have a bigger problem than slavery.

» You can also:
- - - - -
The above is a reply to the following message:
Re: The Failing Ukraine Counteroffensive And It's UGLY Aftermath
By: Zimbler0 in 6TH POPE
Thu, 22 Jun 23 7:04 AM 		Msg. 43703 of 58519

Fiz > Again, I suggest you read up (actually both of us read up more) on Ottoman and even earlier MAJOR civilizations based out of the people and even the religion we now call Islam.

>>>
Islamic views on slavery
Islamic views on slavery represent a complex and multifaceted body of Islamic thought, with various Islamic groups or thinkers espousing views on the matter which have been radically different throughout history. Slavery was a mainstay of life in pre-Islamic Arabia and surrounding lands.
>>>

Fiz,
Back before the British Empire EVERY Empire and every peoples practiced slavery. Granted, there were some empires that 'co-opted the locals' and thereby managed to build an empire stronger and longer lasting than many others. But in those days slavery was a common practice all over the world.

But where most peoples on this planet eventually outlawed slavery - islam seems to still accept it.

I believe your original question was "Where will the next 'Shining City on a Hill' be found?

And I believe that that 'shining city' was due to America's attempt to enshrine 'Human Rights' in the Constitution - and NONE of the empires of antiquity had any such thing as a 'Bill of Rights'.

I do not believe America is in the 'empire business' any more - but Russia, China, and a lot of other countries are, or would be if they thought they could get away with it. And I don't believe any of the 'empire builders' care about 'Human Rights'.

I found this to be an interesting article.

>>>
http://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/countries-that-still-have-slavery

Countries that Still Have Slavery 2023
>>>

Seems slavery is more widespread on this planet than I thought it was . . .

Zim.

« 6TH POPE Home | Email msg. | Reply to msg. | Post new | Board info. Previous | Home | Next